Crime, Liberty and the Forgotten Rights of Society
/ RN Prasher
- Posted: November 16, 2026
- Updated: 12:12 PM
The overlapping interests of three distinct entities are hurt by every crime: the victim, the state and society. In criminal trials, the state, as the prosecutor, plays the dominant role while the victim’s interest remains peripheral. Society, until recent times, remained out of the loop. The significant interest recently taken by social groups through traditional and social media has sometimes resulted in speedy trials but has more often been labelled “trial by media” by the accused and certain groups on the left.
In Sri Surjit Das and others v. Union of India, the Supreme Court on 5 November 2026 expressed disagreement with the coordinate-bench decision in State of Punjab v. Sukhvinder Singh @ Gora and held that, in case of a conflict, Constitutional protections shall reign supreme over special laws. Such a conflict is usually seen regarding the question of enlarging the accused on bail when the trial has become unduly long. The executive is certainly remiss when a trial cannot be brought to a speedy conclusion. Simultaneously, judicial delays also play a role, though, the state is blamed for not filling judicial vacancies promptly. Meanwhile, a dreaded criminal gets released on bail because of the failure of one or more components of the state, leaving society exposed not only to another crime by the accused but also to the accused influencing the trial by influencing the witnesses, particularly because witness protection is not very effective.
The social interest hurt by crime includes the expectation that people can live, work and move about without violence or intimidation. A robbery deprives someone of property, but repeated robberies can make a neighbourhood fearful. An assault injures one person, but unpunished assaults weaken everyone’s confidence in public protection. Crime therefore raises a question at the heart of political life: how should society protect itself without giving the state powers that can themselves become instruments of injustice? Authoritarian systems tend to answer by privileging state authority. Democracies place greater emphasis on restraining that authority and protecting the individual. There are compelling reasons for this difference. Yet democratic criminal justice also faces a legitimate criticism: in protecting the accused against the state, it can lose sight of the victim and the wider community. It may not be wholly true to say that the state protects society’s interests too and that the prosecutor takes care of social interest. Democracy produces, by definition, a partisan executive and it is left to the judiciary to take care of the interests of the unrepresented sections. The judiciary, however, is obliged to maintain the sanctity of the Constitution, which for all practical purposes, translates into safeguarding the rights of the accused. Can we move away from the binaries of unchecked repression and unashamed empowering of the state by undemocratic states on the one hand and the counter-productive Constitutional liberalism of democracies on the other—a situation which makes liberty and social order mutually destructive? Can the society be protected effectively from depredations of criminals while ensuring that innocent people will not be punished merely under pressure from society?
Crime, particularly of a heinous kind, creates an uncomfortable scenario. A large number of people may have witnessed it and there may be electronic and forensic evidence linking the crime to the accused and yet, for years, the accused may be around with the label of “presumption of innocence.” Even the most verifiable and credible accusation cannot be called proof of guilt until it is held so after a trial, and rightly so. Police officers can make mistakes, witnesses can misidentify suspects, and evidence can be unreliable or fabricated. Even an entirely sincere public demand for punishment cannot establish who committed an offence and hence the presumption of innocence.
This presumption is recognised by Article 14 of the International Covenant on Civil and Political Rights alongside an independent tribunal, adequate defence facilities, access to legal assistance and trial without undue delay. The state has the burden of proving guilt beyond a reasonable doubt as well as of conducting the trial through a fair and transparent process. No wonder the conviction rate in democracies is much lower than that in totalitarian regimes like China, where more than 99% of criminal cases end in conviction based on the confession of the accused. In India, it stands at about 54%. The remaining 46% were not all falsely accused, though some may be. The bulk of these cases are when, as everyone ‘knows,’ the accused was guilty but the state failed in its obligation to place credible evidence before the court.
After long delays, all the accused in the Nithari murder case were acquitted, the master of the horror house was acquitted in 2023 while the servant became guilt-free in 2025 after spending 19 years in prison. The master was freed due to a lack of evidence and serious investigation lapses. In the servant’s case, the Supreme Court had upheld his conviction and death sentence in one case holding that the accused’s confession was voluntary and in sync with the circumstantial events. The High Court punched holes in the alleged confession and acquitted him in 12 other cases. Then, the Supreme Court too acquitted him in the 13th case. Skeletal remains of at least 19 individuals, young women and children, were recovered from the drains and backyard of the horror house. Procedure and the rights of the accused won over the fact of the murders and nobody was found guilty. The outcome was no different in the murder of 14-year-old Arushi Talwar and a domestic servant. The girl’s parents were acquitted eight years after the crime with the court holding that the CBI had failed to prove the couple’s guilt beyond reasonable doubt. Society may hold certain beliefs about who was guilty and yet, however disruptive these may be of the social expectation of justice, society cannot penetrate the stone wall of due process.
In India, criminal cases are titled as State or Union versus the accused; in the US, in some states like California or New York, both strongholds of Left-leaning voters, it is People versus the accused. In the US, the conviction rate in federal criminal cases is above 90% while at state-level, it sometimes goes up to 80% with a median of 70%. Trials in the US are much shorter than in India. Despite the fact that constitutionally, the US is a due-process country while India is not, the US has a magic bullet that shortens most of the trials; it is called plea-bargaining. The prosecutor negotiates with the accused and the latter usually agrees to plead guilty to a lesser charge and thereafter, the court promptly convicts the accused. Some will argue that the “bargaining” violates due process. Others will expect that a short trial and high conviction rate would act as a deterrent to future criminals. On the contrary, the US has a very high crime rate and the highest prison population among democratic countries. The US is rich; in the EU, the poorer countries have a much higher incarceration rate than the richer ones. Only the naïve will look for a simple correlation between economy, state, societyand crime rate.
Coming back to India and the present writer’s experience in the Indian Administrative Service, the Sessions Judge, District Magistrate and the Superintendent of Police conduct periodic inspections of the prisons in their jurisdiction. They record the cases where trials have been pending for a long time. The reports are “seen and filed” with hardly any action taken. Maybe, someday, the Supreme Court will oblige these officers to also send an “action taken report” about such cases. Such steps may prevent India from drifting into plea bargaining, which is but a euphemism for bargained confession.
(DAILY WORLD)